Holle Goat Dutch vs HiPP Goat Dutch: An Honest Review

85 hours of research 6 minute read

" Goat milk infant formulas are preferred for sensitive tummies because these have proven a good and safe alternative to cow’s milk. "
Holle Goat vs HiPP Goat

Cow’s milk-based infant formulas often seem to be the “go-to option” for a lot of parents. But what if your baby’s stomach cannot tolerate cow’s milk?

In this article, we are going to discuss two of the best-selling goat milk-based formulas that are a safe choice for many parents: Holle Goat Dutch and HiPP Dutch Goat formula.

Holle Goat Dutch Vs HiPP Goat - Head to Head!

Holle, as a brand, is often regarded as the "clean" goat milk formula with very basic ingredient composition. It is seen as the long-term market leader in goat milk with a lot of historical heritage and consistency. Holle also offers a “PRE” version that can be given to premature babies, whereas HiPP offers only stages 1-3.

On the other hand, HiPP is seen as the goat milk formula with helpful additives (prebiotics) that play a key role in maintaining infants’ health. HiPP as a brand is regarded as a newer entrant into the goat milk formula market, but decades of preliminary product research enabled HiPP to launch the latest and most robust goat milk product in the market. It also offers a characteristic premium can packaging experience to its customers in comparison to Holle's plain boxed packaging.

HiPP Goat contains inositol while its Holle counterpart lacks it. Unlike other carbohydrates, inositol is not digested and used for energy; rather, it is absorbed and used as a building block for other compounds.

Moreover, Galacto-oligosaccharide (GOS) is only present in HiPP Goat. Galacto-oligosaccharide (GOS) is a short-chain galactose with a terminal glucose molecule. Studies have shown that GOS can selectively stimulate the development of Bifidobacteria.

On the hand, Holle Goat Dutch offers a higher concentration of iron which can help in the development of the baby's brain and neurological development. Also, iron is a key component of hemoglobin.

There are quite a few similarities between both of these products. The first and foremost is their availability in the same package sizes (though one comes in a can vs the other in a box). Both of these brands offer organic goat’s milk in their products. In addition, both of these infant milk formulas are A2 milk. Goat milk naturally contains A2 casein proteins. A2 milk is easier to digest and absorb when compared to other varieties of milk types.

Holle Goat Dutch Formula Review

Holle Goat

Holle has been serving parents for over 85 years with their best range of baby formulas that go beyond expectations. Holle strictly adheres to the European organic standards and focuses more on avoiding unnecessary ingredients. All Holle formulas carry the Demeter (organic ++) seal, meaning that animals are fed on biodynamic farms where they are allowed to graze freely, thus maintaining animal welfare standards and ecosystem preservation.

Holle Goat Dutch formula is manufactured with grass-fed goats raised on Demeter farms. Having Demeter certification means the product comes straight from Biodynamic farms. Demeter-certified biodynamic farms use the world’s most sustainable farming practices to ensure that their products are full of love, care, and nutrition. Besides safe products, biodynamic farmers ensure their animals are raised in caring environments.

All stages of Holle Goat Dutch formula are formulated with strict EU regulations, ensuring high standards for the safety of organic ingredients and high animal care standards. If you want your sensitive baby to drink all-natural formula, opt for the Holle Goat Dutch formula line.

Holle Goat Dutch Nutritional Features & Ingredients

  • Certified organic by the European Commission
  • Demeter certified
  • No genetic engineering or modification with GMOs (genetically modified organisms).
  • Contains all the necessary ingredients, including A2 milk, calcium, vitamin A, C, and D, and healthy fatty acids.
  • Reinforced formula cans for better packaging
  • No man-made additives
  • Contains essential nutrients, ensuring they are safe and healthy for your baby.

Holle Goat Dutch Stages

The Holle Goat Dutch formula comes in three stages to meet the nutritional requirements of your little one:

Age: 0-6 months

No palm oil

Contains natural whey, DHA, & ALA

Demeter certified (Organic++)

Check Price
Holle Goat Dutch stage 1
  • Why Choose? This whole organic baby formula is formulated for babies aged up to six months. For parents looking for an alternative to cow’s milk, Holle Goat Dutch stage 1 is the best choice. The stage 1 formula is free of:
    • Artificial flavorings
    • Synthetic chemicals
    • Corn syrup or corn syrup solids
    • Added sugars
    • GMOs
    • Soy
    • Gluten

    Check Price

The stage 1 formula contains all the essential nutrients required for early infancy development. The goat milk offered in Holle Goat Dutch stage 1 formula is A2 milk, which is great for sensitive tummies. Goat milk used in stage 1 formula is rich in calcium, phosphorus, and vitamin A, C, and D to support healthy bones.

Age: 6-12 months

No palm oil

Contains natural whey, DHA, & ALA

Demeter certified (Organic++)

Check Price
Holle Goat Dutch stage 2

Holle Goat Dutch Stage 2 formula has been specially designed for sensitive tummies which cannot tolerate cow’s milk protein. The stage 2 formula is perfect for infants six months and older. The goat milk enzymes in the formula make it easier to digest and reduce bloating and constipation.

Holle Goat Dutch Stage 2 is rich in natural lactose, contains A2 milk, and contains essential nutrients to promote infant development. The stage 2 formula is also free of any preservatives and additives. The A2 milk in the formula promotes a healthy gut microbiome.

Age: 10+ months

No palm oil

Contains natural whey, DHA, & ALA

Demeter certified (Organic++)

Check Price
Holle Goat Dutch stage 3

Holle Goat Dutch Stage 3 formula is ideal for babies of 10+ months. The toddler formula is exceptionally rich in nutrients and easier to digest. Stage 3 formula has lower levels of natural sugars and higher levels of protein, which is helpful for aiding constipation and gassiness.

Stage 3 is perfect for toddlers transitioning to solid foods or infants who have previously been on a breast milk diet.

Benefits Of Holle Goat Dutch Formula

  • Contains less lactose than cow’s milk formulas
  • Demeter certified
  • Contains clean ingredients list to prevent sensitive stomach issues
  • Contains A2 milk
  • Goats are raised on biodynamic farms
  • No added sugar, soy oil, palm oil
  • No preservatives, flavors, and chemicals
  • Less sugar, more calcium, and vitamins
  • Easier to digest
  • Prevents constipation, bloating, and gassiness

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula Review

HiPP Goat

Another great formula for babies who cannot tolerate cow’s milk protein is HiPP Dutch Goat Formula, which contains wholesome A2 goat milk. The formula comes with the “organic” seal, meaning that it uses 95% organic ingredients to promote your baby’s health. The formula is rich in prebiotics, omega 3 fatty acids, and essential vitamins and minerals.

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula Nutritional Features & Ingredients

  • All stages are formulated with clean A2 goat milk
  • Use of 100% organic ingredients, which are clean and wholesome
  • Prebiotic galactooligosaccharides (GOS)
  • Omega-3 and other long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (LCPs)
  • HiPP Organic seal on all stages
  • No man-made additives

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula Stages

HiPP Dutch Goat Formula comes in three stages, with each stage loaded with wholesome ingredients and vital nutrients.

Age: 0-6 months

No palm oil

Contains natural prebiotics

Organic A2 goat milk

Check Price
HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 1

HiPP Dutch Goat stage 1 formula is a clean, A2 goat milk formula that is best suited for babies of 0-6 months. The formula is rich in:

  • Why Choose?
    • Prebiotic GOS - for a healthy gut microbiome
    • Vitamins A, E, B, and D - for healthy bone development
    • Calcium fortified
    • Omega-3 and LCPs

    Check Price

Age: 10-12 months

No palm oil

Contains natural prebiotics

Organic A2 goat milk

Check Price
HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 2

HiPP Dutch Goat stage 2 is a nutritionally complete formula, ideal for babies of 6-12 months. Stage 2 contains reduced protein content so that it’s easier to digest and is gentle on the baby’s stomach. The formula prevents bloating, gas, vomiting, and diarrhea.

Age: 12+ months

No palm oil

Contains natural prebiotics

Organic A2 goat milk

Check Price
HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 3

HiPP Dutch Goat stage 3 formula is well-tolerated by infants of 12 months and older. The A2 goat milk is free of GMOs, maltodextrin, wheat, gluten, soy, and any other synthetic preservatives.

Benefits Of HiPP Dutch Goat Formula

  • Eu certified organic
  • Prebiotic GOS for maintaining gut microbiome
  • Only lactose as a natural sweetener
  • Highly digestible
  • Aids constipation, bloating, gas, nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting
  • Well-tolerated by sensitive babies
  • A nutritionally complete formula that tastes phenomenal
  • No GMOs

Why Choose Goat’s Milk Formula?

Holle Goat vs HiPP Goat 2

Goat milk and cow milk have unique variations in their micronutrient as well as macronutrient composition. What does that mean for new parents? The makeup and minerals of goat’s milk are different from cow’s milk. This composition contains a different type of fat content and less lactose, which offer the advantage of being easier on the infant’s digestive system.

Regarding nutritional composition, goat and cow milk have different concentrations of fatty acids, vitamins, minerals, fat structures, and milk protein (casein to whey protein ratio). Goat milk holds less allergenic properties because it contains a minimal proportion of alpha-S1 casein, which induces allergic reactions. Cow milk contains more of this particular allergy-causing protein. Therefore, infants who are allergic to cow’s milk can tolerate goat milk easily. Overall, goat milk vs. cow milk is fairly equal nutritionally unless you are specifically looking for a higher or lower amount of any of these key nutrients.

Furthermore, cow milk protein forms a harder curd in the infant’s stomach. On the other hand, goat milk creates a much softer curd in the stomach; that’s why it is easier to digest.

In a nutshell, both cow and goat milk formulas are wholesome and nutritious, but goat’s milk can prove to be a better choice if your child has a sensitive tummy.

What Are The Benefits Of Goat’s Milk?

Holle Goat vs HiPP Goat 3

The following are some proven benefits that goat milk offers:

1. No Synthetic Hormones

In manufacturing organic formulas, goats are rarely given synthetic hormones because these hormones can cause digestive problems in infants. They also make the condition worse when your child is already suffering from lactose intolerance and indigestion. Goat’s milk is free of any genetic modifications and specifications, meaning that you’re feeding your baby the best and wholesome nutrients.

2. Less Lactose

If your little one has lactose intolerance, goat’s milk can be a safe option. It contains less lactose than cow’s milk.

3. Nutritional Value

Do you know goat’s milk contains all the vital nutrients responsible for your baby’s healthy growth and development? Goat’s milk contains about 35% calcium. Goat milk offers around 9 grams of protein per cup, which is 1 more than that of cow milk. Goat milk contains more vitamin A, vitamin C (cow milk has none), magnesium, vitamin B1, and considerably more potassium. All of these nutrients promote the healthy development of vital organs in your baby. Being known as “bio-organic sodium animals,” goats produce milk that contributes to joint health. Also, it benefits your baby by supporting their nervous system.

Goat milk offers around 9 grams of protein per cup, which is 1 more than that of cow milk. Goat milk contains more vitamin A, vitamin C (cow milk has none), magnesium, vitamin B1, and considerably more potassium.

4. Boosts The Immune System

Goat’s milk is a fantastic source of selenium, which is a crucial mineral to modulate and boost the immunity your baby needs. It is true that every mommy wishes protection from sickness for their baby; trace amounts of selenium in goat’s milk can help protect your baby from illnesses.

5. Reduces inflammation

Compared to cow’s milk, goat’s milk is smoother in composition and does not cause any inflammation. Goat’s milk formula definitely is the obvious choice when your little one is experiencing bowel inflammation. The digestion ease and nutritional benefits of a goat milk formula make it a safer and better choice for newborn babies. There is nothing harmful in goat’s milk that causes inflammation in your baby’s insides.

Holle Goat Dutch and HiPP Goat Dutch

The first few months and years of your baby’s life are very important in terms of their development and growth. So, it is always a good idea to invest in a premium and safe formula with no synthetic ingredients. Goat milk formulas happen to be the healthy choice for babies who cannot tolerate cow milk or are allergic to cow milk protein.

Holle Goat Dutch and HiPP Dutch Goat are the two formulas that should not be missed. These non-toxic alternatives to cow’s milk ensure your baby is digesting goat’s milk easily with good tolerability. For more information, head out to our website to make the right feeding choices for your baby.

Meanwhile, if you're in search of the cow milk version of these formulas, we also offer HiPP Dutch (HiPP Dutch Stage 1, HiPP Dutch Stage 2, HiPP Dutch Stage 3, and HiPP Dutch Stage 4) as well as Holle Bio Organic formula (Holle Bio Stage PRE, Holle Bio Stage 1, Holle Bio Stage 2, Holle Bio Stage 3, and Holle Bio Stage 4). If you're interested in getting HiPP and Holle formulas, don't hesitate to contact us. We'll be delighted to assist you in securing these products for your baby's optimal nourishment and digestive comfort.

Most Popular Holle Goat Dutch Formula

  1. Holle Goat Dutch Stage 1
  2. Holle Goat Dutch Stage 2
  3. Holle Goat Dutch stage 3

Most Popular HiPP Dutch Goat Formula

  1. HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 1
  2. HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 2
  3. HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 3